Driver of Change

Cultural and Social Paradigms

Overview

This driver explores the dynamic transformation of societal values and cultural norms that shape human interactions and institutional structures.

This driver of change refers to how changes in individuals and communities frameworks and sets of beliefs, values, practices, and social norms shape their behaviour. Across historical epochs, Christianity and the Church have been shaped by evolving cultural paradigms. As global connectivity and cultural exchanges intensify, traditional beliefs and practices are increasingly questioned and redefined. An example of this is can be seen in evolving experience of modernity, post-modernity, and now late/liquid modernity all of which lead to a broader reconsideration of identity, ethics, and community roles.

For Christian leaders, understanding and engaging with cultural and social paradigms is crucial because these paradigms influence how faith is practiced, understood, and lived out among believers and within broader communities. Practically, this driver of change and it’s respective trends highlight ways that ministry frameworks, approaches, and models are challenged and offering possible faithful new forms of ways to approach Christian ministry.

Macro Trends

Rapid Societal Change

Trend Description
This trend refers to the swift and significant transformations that increasingly occurring in various aspects of Canadian society, including its culture, economy, technology, norms, values, and institutions. All of which influence churches and individuals within them.

Reflective Question
Despite the rapid rate of change, what are aspects of Christian faith and life that rise above these changes?

Rapid Societal Change

Individualism

Trend Description
Individualism is a philosophical, social, and cultural perspective that emphasizes the value and autonomy of the individual over the collective or group. This perspective is often held by individuals holding a Eurocentric/western worldview.

Reflective Question
What is the impact of increased individualism when considering faith formation and the mission of the church?

Individualism

Secularism

Trend Description
Secularism is a philosophy or worldview that advocates for the separation of religion from government, public institutions, and civic affairs. It promotes a society in which religious considerations are distinct from political and social decision-making.

Reflective Question
In a secular context, how do we live out our beliefs authentically, contribute positively to society, and promote values that align with our Christian principles?

Secularism

Socio-Cultural Reformation/Counter-Hegemony

Trend Description
Refers to a societal shift where marginalized groups challenge prevailing cultural norms, power structures, and dominant narratives. It involves efforts to redefine social values, promote inclusivity, and challenge existing systems of oppression.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders engage with societal shifts, challenge oppressive systems, and contribute to positive transformation?

Socio-Cultural Reformation/Counter-Hegemony

Decolonization

Decolonization

Trend Description
Decolonization is a process aimed at dismantling and undoing the historical legacy of colonization. It involves addressing and rectifying the social, cultural, political, and economic impacts of colonial rule on indigenous or colonized peoples. The Canadian church has a troubling connection with the historical and ongoing oppression of the Indigenous, Metis, and Inuit people.

Reflective Question
What does it mean for Churches to pursue reconciliation?

Increased emphasis on diversity and inclusion

Increased emphasis on diversity and inclusion

Trend Description
This trend refers to the broad emphasis across industries and sectors encouraging and supporting more welcoming and accessible spaces. This trend relates to various intersections of identity including cultural background, gender, physical and mental abilities.

Reflective Question
What does Scripture offer when considering the concept of creating spaces of welcoming and belonging?

Socio-Valorization

Socio-Valorization

Trend Description
This trend involves the recognition and enhancement of the value and contributions of individuals and groups within society, particularly those who have been marginalized or overlooked. It emphasizes the promotion of dignity, respect, and inclusion for all members of the community.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders reflect the teachings of Christ in fostering dignity, respect, and inclusivity for those who may be marginalized or overlooked?

Cultural Pluralism

Cultural Pluralism

Trend Description
This trend recognizes the coexistence of diverse cultural identities within a society and advocates for different cultural groups maintaining their unique practices, values, and traditions while contributing to the larger social fabric.

Reflective Question
How can churches embrace and contribute to the trend of cultural pluralism, fostering understanding and harmony among diverse cultural identities?

Economic & Political Interests

Trend Description
This trend involves the way individuals, groups, or nations navigate, influence, and balance diverse interests in the economic and political realms, often impacting policies and societal structures.

Reflective Question
What are church leaders doing to understand and ensure their values uphold justice, fairness, and the well-being of all individuals?

Economic & Political Interests

Cultural Backlash

Cultural Backlash

Trend Description
This trend refers to the reactions against progressive cultural changes. It involves resistance to shifts in societal norms, often driven by concerns about the erosion of traditional values or identities.

Reflective Question
Church leaders may resonate with the concerns of those resisting progressive cultural shifts, but in what way might we offer a distinctive Christian voice?

Identity Politics

Identity Politics

Trend Description
This trend is where individuals form political alliances based on shared social identities, such as race, gender, or ethnicity. It influences political discourse and policy discussions.

Reflective Question
Social identities often shape political alliances, how do we promote unity and understanding across diverse backgrounds within our faith communities?

Rising Authoritarianism

Rising Authoritarianism

Trend Description
This trend highlights the increasing concentration of power in leaders or governments, often at the expense of democratic principles and individual freedoms.

Reflective Question
In the face of authoritarian tendencies, how can church leaders actively promote accountability, transparency, and compassion within our communities?

Rising Nationalism

Rising Nationalism

Trend Description
This trend highlights the increasing emphasis on national interests, often accompanied by a sense of cultural or political exclusivity.

Reflective Question
How do we balance patriotic sentiments with the biblical call for inclusivity and care for the well-being of all people, regardless of national borders?

Consumerism

Trend Description
This trend refers to how acquisition, capitalism, and display of goods and services becomes a significant part of people’s lives, shaping their behaviors, aspirations, and perceptions of self-worth.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders address the impact of consumerism and provide meaningful alternatives to its behaviours?

Consumerism

Mental health & Wellbeing

Trend Description
This trend is related to the rise of education, awareness, and prevalence of mental health & wellbeing with Canadian society. Mental health refers to a person’s emotional and psychological well-being, encompassing their ability to handle stress, maintain relationships, and cope with life’s challenges effectively. It involves emotional, cognitive, and social functioning.

Reflective Question
How can churches and church leaders support the mental wellbeing of congregants?

Mental health & Wellbeing

Environmental Concerns

Trend Description
Climate change and global warning have been prominent topics of discussion for 20 years, however, . increasingly Canadians are considering what actions can be taken.

Reflective Question
What does creation care mean to your church?

Environmental Concerns

Relativism

Trend Description
Relativism is the philosophical view that denies absolute truths and asserts that truth, morality, and knowledge are subjective and context dependent. In Christianity, this poses a challenge to the belief in objective truths based on the teachings of the Bible. This has been fed by post-modernity and continues into late modernity.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders and churches engage with a society which does not respect or validate the sources of authority informing Christian teaching and beliefs?

Relativism

Pluralism

Trend Description
Pluralism is defined as the occurrence of people of different social classes, religions, races, etc., are together in a context or more broadly in society, and that they continue to maintain their different traditions and interests.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders articulate the goodness and uniqueness of Christianity in a pluralistic context?

Pluralism

Micro Trends

Understanding of ‘authority’

Trend Description
In a post-modern/late-modern society, authority has shifted from traditional sources of unquestioned power and hierarchy to a more decentralized, diverse, and questioned form. Authority is now often derived from personal experience, expertise, and individual perspectives, leading to a greater emphasis on dialogue, shared knowledge, and participatory decision-making.

Reflective Question
How does this shift in understanding authority influence the church?

Understanding of ‘authority’

Mistrust of the ‘expert’

Mistrust of the ‘expert’

Trend Description
Along with the shift in the Understanding of Authority identified above, an increased scrutiny of individuals who are considered ‘experts’ in any field has emerged. This is connected to various other trends; however, it is relevant to the church as not only are institutions mistrusted, but individuals’ expertise in subject areas is not assumed simply based on degrees or title.

Reflective Question
What is the role of ‘experts’ in the Christian church?

Virtue Signaling

Trend Description
This trend is the act of individuals or organizations publicly expressing a moral or virtuous beliefs, opinions, or values primarily to gain social approval, recognition, or to appear morally superior, rather than genuinely promoting positive change or taking meaningful action to support those beliefs.

Reflective Question
How can churches go beyound virtue signally to meaningful action?

Virtue Signaling

Sense of Instability

Trend Description
Canadian society is experiencing ongoing change. The result of this amount of change can create a sense of instability and uncertainty for individuals. This can relate to their employment, family, education, and even affect their personal values and beliefs. This is relevant to the church as congregants will also experience this instability when considering their faith.

Reflective Question
ow can church leaders create communities which are aware and engage in the instability of Canadian society, but also provide a stable space for individuals to ground themselves?

Sense of Instability

Increasing anxiety

Increasing anxiety

Trend Description
Anxiety is one of the most prominent mental health challenges faced by Canadians. Anxiety is a natural emotional response characterized by feelings of unease, worry, or fear, often related to anticipated future events or uncertainties. It is particularly common in younger generations.

Reflective Question
How does the Christian faith speak to anxiety?

Importance of Representation

Trend Description
This trend, emphasizes the recognition of the significance of having individuals who reflect diverse facets of identity, such as culture, gender, age, etc., in prominent and authoritative roles. This inclusivity empowers people who identify with these intersections of identity to visualize themselves in a wide range of roles and spaces.

Reflective Question
Does your church leadership team represent the diversity in your church/community in terms of culture, gender, age, and other identity aspects?

Importance of Representation

Deepening social and political divide

Trend Description
Around the world, there is an increased separation between individuals holding differing political, social, or religious views.

Reflective Question
As Christians, we are called by God “to live at peace with everyone” (Romans 12:18) which includes actively engaging in conversations that lead towards true restoration. How can churches support this in such a divisive period of time?

Deepening social and political divide

Rise of ‘Manosphere’

Rise of ‘Manosphere’

Trend Description
The manosphere is a network of online men’s communities against the empowerment of women and who promote anti-feminist perspectives.

Reflective Question
How can the church be a community where men can discover what healthy masculinity looks like while also being safe, welcoming, and empowering for women?

White fragility

White fragility

Trend Description
Author Robin DiAngelo, defined white fragility as: “a state in which even a minimum amount of racial stress becomes intolerable, triggering a range of defensive moves.” (Saad, 2020, 41, quoting DiAngelo White Fragility 2018, 103) Resulting from increased societal discourse and awareness about racism and the intentional and historical systems which have supported and better the lives of white European settlers in Canada are being challenged. Decolonization and movements like Black Lives Matter which strive to articulate the systematic injustices have resulted in increased discussion about racial and social injustice.

Reflective Question
How can the church and church leaders create spaces where conversations about injustice and racism can occur?

Social Wedge Issues

Social Wedge Issues

Trend Description
This trend refers to the emergence of divisive and polarizing topics or controversies. These topics often related to social, cultural, or political issues. They can form wedges between friends, family, acquitences, and within communities of faith resulting in breakdown of relationship and connection. These divides can occur when opinions are held without a willingness to hear differing or conflicting perspectives or experiences and lead to tensions and disagreements within the faith community. This trend has a political element to it.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders engage with these divisive topics and maintain unity?

Squeezing of the ‘middle’

Squeezing of the ‘middle’

Trend Description

With the loss of rational dialogue, it is increasingly challenging for individuals to strive to stand in the middle of social and political topics. Often, these individuals will be judged by both sides as either being too liberal or too conservative.

Reflective Question
Given that no human political system can be perfect (or perfectly reflect God’s kingdom?), Christians will often find themselves in the middle and not fit entirely with one political system. In what ways should Christians bravely stand in the middle in order to not compromise tenets of the faith, not compromising either to the right or the left?

Loss of rational dialogue

Loss of rational dialogue

Trend Description
As result of the increased social and political divide, there is an increased lack of ability for individuals holding differing perspective to engage in civil and meaningful discussion.

Reflective Question
How can Church leaders and churches engage in meaningful discussion with organizations or individuals who hold differing views from them?

Push against ‘wokeism’

Push against ‘wokeism’

Trend Description
As society continues to engage in naming and addressing the historical and intentional injustices in place, a counter movement of ‘anti-wokeness’ is emerging.

Reflective Question
How can churches share a local table fellowship together with individuals holding differing views?

Challenging and dismantling of historical systems

Trend Description
This trend involves questioning and deconstructing established social, political, or economic structures and practices that have perpetuated inequality or injustice. This trend seeks to reform or replace these systems to create more equitable, inclusive, and just societies. It often arises in response to historical injustices and is driven by movements advocating for change and progress.

Reflective Question
How does the church navigate being a historical institution in today’s context?

Challenging and dismantling of historical systems

Increased Loneliness

Trend Description
Directly connected to the rise of social media and exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic the experience of individuals feeling alone and separate has dramatically increased and is identified as one of the key contributors to poor mental health.

Reflective Question
What role does the Christian faith have in supporting people in their loneliness?

Increased Loneliness

Social Constructivism

Trend Description
A theoretical perspective emphasizing the role of social interactions and cultural context in building knowledge and understanding.

Reflective Question
What insights and implications does social constructivism offer and present to the faith formation of the next generation?

Social Constructivism

Ecclesial Trends

Deconstruction

Trend Description
This refers to a process of critically examining and reevaluating one’s beliefs, doctrines, and assumptions within the context of Christianity. It involves questioning and analyzing traditional theological concepts, religious practices, and interpretations of scripture. This process can result in positive outcomes such as gaining deeper insights, challenge dogma, and arrive at a more authentic and personally meaningful understanding of faith. However, it can also result in potential negative outcomes such as a complete loss or rejection of faith.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders create safe and constructive spaces to support people as they engage in deconstructive thinking?

Deconstruction

Post-Christendom

Trend Description
Canada has socially and culturally shifted away from the dominance and influence of the Christian worldview. Canada is now in a period in which Christian beliefs, practices, and institutions no longer hold the central or privileged position they once did in shaping the culture and values of society.

Reflective Question
How does this shift from Christianity no longer being the dominant worldview influence the way churches live out their mission in this Canadian context?

Post-Christendom

Fading tradition and historical knowledge

Fading tradition and historical knowledge

Trend Description
This trend refers to the diminishing familiarity and knowledge of church tradition and history. This is particularly poignant for local congregations as the history of local churches is being lost.

Reflective Question
How can the tradition and history of local congregations be celebrated and passed on to future generations (without idolizing it)?

Nostalgia

Nostalgia

Trend Description
Refers to the sentimental longing or affection for the past. It manifests in various forms, such as cultural revival, vintage aesthetics, and a yearning for experiences or traditions from earlier times.

Reflective Question
What is the value and danger of nostalgia for Christian leaders?

Biblical & socially oriented church mission

Trend Description
A significant shift within society has been the increased value and focus on social justice and equity. Congregants have increasing expectations of tangibly seeing the church being the ‘hands and feet’ of Christ.

Reflective Question
What value or focus are church leaders placing on the role of justice and service?

Biblical & socially oriented church mission

Critical Consumers

Trend Description
The trend of critical consumers in the context of the church refers to how individuals are approaching their faith community with hightened personal discernment and evaluation of the church’s teachings, values, practices, and how it aligns with their personal expectations and principles. It reflects a shift toward more intentional and selective engagement with religious institutions.

Reflective Question
Why do you believe this trend has gained popularity, and what key factors are people considering when evaluating a church to attend?

Critical Consumers

Decline of qualified and capable pastors

Trend Description
Identified in several articles was the challenge for churches to identify and recruit qualified and capable vocational pastors.

Reflective Question
How could the role and function of a pastors need to change to navigate the new Canadian landscape?

Decline of qualified and capable pastors

Flattening Ecclesiology

Trend Description
Flattening ecclesiology challenges traditional hierarchy and promotes a more horizontal and egalitarian approach. It emphasizes shared leadership, participation, and the priesthood of all believers.

Reflective Question
What does this mean for the role of the pastor?

Flattening Ecclesiology

Grassroots leadership

Grassroots leadership

Trend Description
Grassroots leadership refers to leadership that emerges from the bottom or grassroots level of an organization, community, or movement, rather than being imposed from the top-down. It’s characterized by leadership that originates from the people directly affected by the issues or goals being addressed.

Reflective Question
In a historically ‘top down’ leadership structure, how can church leaders adapt to this new form of leadership?

Loss of pastoral authority

Loss of pastoral authority

Trend Description
Like many other positions of authority, this is a trend highlights that the historical assumption that pastors were spiritual authorities and leaders can no longer be assumed.

Reflective Question
What role does authority (or lack of authority) play in the role of pastors and church leaders?

Personal Spiritual Development/Self-Spirituality

Trend Description
Connected to the trend of individualism, this trend emphasizes the shift toward a more personal approach to spiritual development and understanding. With a particular focus on personal experiences and insights shaping individuals’ relationship with God. The role and authority of the institutional church is seen as irrelevant or unneeded.

Reflective Question
What does this approach to spiritual development mean for the church?

Personal Spiritual Development/Self-Spirituality

Personal Choice & Autonomy

Personal Choice & Autonomy

Trend Description
Self-spirituality emphasizes individual autonomy in matters of belief and practice. This means that individuals develop their own spiritual paths rather than adhering strictly to established religious traditions or statements.

Reflective Question
How can the church come alongside individuals in effective ways to provide the historical and communal wisdom present within the church?

Freedom and Judgement

Freedom and Judgement

Trend Description
This trend refers to the characteristics of individuals wanting to seek their own understanding (freedom), and exercise critical thinking as they pursue their spiritual growth and understanding within the context of Christianity without a sense of external influence or expectation (judgement).

Reflective Question
How can churches approach and offer accountability for congregants holding these values?

Changing approaches and ecclesiological models

Trend Description
As society has shifted, so has the expectations of Christians for their church communities. This trend is historically grounded, as communities of faith have changed and adapted since the time of Jesus. However, the increased rate of change across all facets of Canadian society results in the need to constantly reflect on the ecclesiological models and approaches used.

Reflective Question
How can church leaders balance the tension of being responsive to the changing desires and expectations of congregants for church gatherings, but also recognizing the importance of tradition and history?

Changing approaches and ecclesiological models

Relational approach

Relational approach

Trend Description
Seen across sectors (education, employment) the desire for more relational spaces is an important trend for church leaders to consider. Often this trend refers to taking a human-centred approach and prioritizing building relationships over other elements.

Reflective Question
How could a focus on building relationships change the way church leaders facilitate Sunday morning worship?

Contextually relevant and applied ecclesiology

Contextually relevant and applied ecclesiology

Trend Description
A rising trend of the importance of churches to be locally focused and connected to the community in which they are located. Being engaged in public community life and being an active part of the neighborhood or community is of increasing importance to congregants.

Reflective Question
How connected and engaged is your church to its local context?

Network Church

Network Church

Trend Description
This trend refers to a type of Christian congregation that operates through a decentralized and interconnected structure. Instead of a traditional single-site church with a central building and congregation, a Network Church consists of multiple smaller gatherings and groups linked together by shared values, vision, and often technology.

Reflective Question
What are some of the strengths and weaknesses of the network church model?

Micro Church Movement

Micro Church Movement

Trend Description
This trend refers to an increase in small, intimate, and often decentralized gatherings for worship, fellowship, and discipleship. It is characterized by an emphasis on creating more personal and participatory experiences of church, in contrast to traditional, larger-scale congregational models.

Reflective Question
How can more traditional church models incorporate structures of the micro church movement? Should they?

Evolution of Conservative Christianity

Trend Description
The rise of more conservative and outspoken Christian movements mirrors the rise of more conservative political parties and ideologies.

Reflective Question
Conservative Christianity has always existed, however, in today’s cultural context how can more conservative Christians engage meaningfully and effectively?

Evolution of Conservative Christianity

Rise of Christian Nationalism

Rise of Christian Nationalism

Trend Description
This is a sentiment that aligns the Christian faith with Canadian identity and values. Foundationally, it represents a belief that Canada should be a ‘Christian nation’ and that Canadian Christians will lose their identity and importantly their freedom if we do not preserve our cultural inheritance.

Reflective Question
How can Christian leaders encourage a strong Christian identity without encouraging Christian nationalism?

Increased disillusionment of Evangelicalism

Increased disillusionment of Evangelicalism

Trend Description
A result of both the broader secularization of Canadian society, but also the alignment of evangelicalism and particular political and social ideologies, is resulting in individuals not wanting to be affiliated with evangelicalism and the Church.

Reflective Question
How can the church engage with individuals who feel a sense of shame in being affiliated with the Church institution?

Culturally Relevant Tension

Trend Description
Evangelicals have historically strived to maintain a conservative Christian belief, while engaging with society around them. The current social landscape and increased political divide has increased the complexity for many churches.

Reflective Question
What are foundational elements of faith which can be firm anchor points for the church seeking to engage their broader community?

Culturally Relevant Tension

Softening or Gracious Orthodoxy

Softening or Gracious Orthodoxy

Trend Description
Some churches have adapted their practices, theology, and doctrine to create more welcoming church communities, as informed by broader social values.

Reflective Question
What is the danger of gracious orthodoxy and how do Christian leaders navigate these challenges?

Spiritual Hunger

Trend Description
This trend denotes the desire for meaningful spiritual experiences, exploration, and connection. Individuals experiencing this trend seek deeper connections with their faith, often beyond traditional religious structures.

Reflective Question
In fostering a space where individuals seeking deeper spiritual connections feel embraced and supported, what intentional practices and approaches can be implemented to facilitate meaningful engagement and nourishment?

Spiritual Hunger

Reflective Questions

How can we find a healthy balance between honoring timeless Christian traditions and embracing innovative approaches to ministry that resonate with late-modern generations?

How can our congregation embrace and engage with the global nature of late-modern society, fostering cross-cultural understanding and collaboration in our mission?

Late-modern cultures value authenticity. How can we as leaders model transparency and vulnerability while maintaining a posture of spiritual authority?

How might we engage with the skepticism and distrust of institutions that characterize late-modern thought, while remaining rooted and connected to the teaching of Jesus?

In a culture that emphasizes individual autonomy, how can we foster a sense of authentic community and belonging within our congregation?

How can we engage with the diverse range of worldviews and perspectives that characterize post-modern societies while remaining faithful to our Christian beliefs?

Related Horizon Resources

futuring compass

INSIGHT PORTAL

Is there a trend you have noticed that could impact the future of the church? We value input from our community!

Learn more about contributing a future insight.

Give today for a brighter tomorrow

Support the shaping of a vision for the future of the church.

Enquire about partnership oppportunities with The Futuring Hub today!

Study with purpose

If you are interested in pursuing the questions of faith and culture, consider studying with Acadia Divinity College. Explore our program options or speak to our recruitment department today!

Menu